Friday, January 29, 2010

JAVA vs C++

JAVA vs C++


http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~hasti/cs368/JavaTutorial/

Contents


In Java, every variable, constant, and function (including main) must be inside some class. Here's a simple example program:
 	class Test { 		public static void main( String [] args ) 		{ 		    System.out.println("Hello world!"); 		} 	}  
Things to note:
  1. There is no final semi-colon at the end of the class definition.

  2. Function main is a member of class Test.

  3. In general, main must:
    • Be inside some class (there can be more than one main function -- there can even be one in every class!)
    • Be public static void.
    • Have one argument: an array of String. This array contains the command-line arguments. You can use args.length to determine the number of arguments (the number of Strings in the array).

  4. To write to standard output, you can use either of the following:
    	System.out.println( ... ) 	System.out.print( ... )     
    The former prints the given expression followed by a newline, while the latter just prints the given expression.

    Like the C++ <<>

    	System.out.print("hello");   // print a String 	System.out.print(16);        // print an integer 	System.out.print(5.5 * .2);  // print a floating-point number        

    The + operator can be useful when printing. It is overloaded to work on Strings as follows:

    If either operand is a String, it

    1. converts the other operand to a String (if necessary)
    2. creates a new String by concatenating both operands

    Example

    	int x = 20, y = 10; 	System.out.println("x: " + x + "\ny: " + y);        
    The output is:
           x: 20        y: 10        
    This is because the argument to println is an expression of the form:
      op1 + op2 + op3 + op4

    The only operator is +, so the expression is evaluated left-to-right (if there were another operator with higher precedence, the sub-expression involving that operator would be evaluated first). The leftmost sub-expression is:

      "x: " + x
    One operand (the left one) is a String, so the other operand is converted from an int to a String, and the two strings are concatenated, producing the value:
      "x: 20"

    Evaluation of the argument to println continues, producing as the final value the String shown above (note that \n means the newline character):

    	x: 20  	y: 10        

TEST YOURSELF #1

Assume the following declarations have been made:

    int x = 20, y = 10; 
What is printed when each of the following statements is executed?
    System.out.println(x + y);     System.out.println(x + y + "!");     System.out.println("printing: " + x + y);     System.out.println("printing: " + x * y); 

solution


C++ Files vs Java Files

A C++ programmer deals with source files, object files, and executable files:

Source Files: .h and .cc (or .cpp or .C)

  created by:  you (the programmer)   contain   :  C++ source code   two kinds :         .h (header files) 	       contain class definitions and function specifications                        (just headers - no bodies)                must be included by every file that uses the class / calls the 	               functions         .cc contain implementations of class member functions and "free" functions, 	            including the main function 	

Object Files: .o

  created by:  the compiler, when called w/ -c flag; for example: 			g++ -c main.cc 	       compiles main.cc creating main.o   contain   :  object code (not executable)                source code is compiled, but not linked/loaded   

Executable Files

  created by:  the compiler (no -c flag)   contain   :  executable code 	 	      Code is compiled if necessary, then linked and loaded. 		      These are the files that you can actually run, just by typing 		      the name of the file.   name      :  default = a.out                any other name is possible via the -o flag; for example: 			g++ main.o -o test  	       creates an executable named "test"   

A Java programmer deals with source files and bytecode files (no executable files):

Source Files: .java

  created by   :  you (the programmer)   contain      :  Java source code (one or more classes per file)   restrictions :      (1) each source file can contain at most one public class      (2) if there is a public class, then the class name and file name must match            Examples      	If a source file contains the following: 		public class Test { ... } 		class Foo { ... } 		class Bar {... } 	then it must be in a file named Test.java 	 	If a source file contains the following: 		class Test { ... } 		class Foo { ... } 		class Bar {... } 	then it can be in any ".java" file 	
Small digression:
  • Every function must be part of a class.
  • Every class is part of a package (packages are discussed in a later set of notes.).
  • A public class can be used in any package.
  • A non-public class can only be used in its own package.
End of digression.

Bytecode Files: .class

  created by:  the Java compiler   contain   :  Java bytecodes, ready to be "executed" -- really interpreted -- by                                the Java interpreter   names     :  for each class in a source file (both public and non-public classes),                the compiler creates one ".class" file, where the file name is the 	       same as the class name    Example      If a source file contains the following: 	public class Test { ... } 	class Foo { ... } 	class Bar {... }      then after compiling you will have three files:      	Test.class 	Foo.class 	Bar.class                  

Here's how to compile and run the example "hello world" program given above, assuming that it is in a file named "tst.java":

  1. to compile the source code, type: javac tst.java

  2. to run the interpreter using the name of the class whose main function you want to run, type: java Test

Remember, when compiling a program, you type the full file name, including the ".java" extension; when running a program, you just type the name of the class whose main function you want to run.


TEST YOURSELF #2

Write a complete Java program that uses a loop to sum the numbers from 1 to 10 and prints the result like this:

    The sum is: xxx 
Note: Use variable declarations, and a for or while loop with the same syntax as in C++.

Make sure that you are able to compile and execute your program!

solution


Java Types

In Java, there are two "categories" of types: primitive types and reference types:

      Primitive Types
    booleansame as bool in C++
    charholds one character
    byte8-bit signed integer
    short16-bit signed integer
    int32-bit signed integer
    long64-bit signed integer
    floatfloating-point number
    doubledouble precision floating-point number
      Reference Types
      arrays
      classes

Notes:

  1. no struct, union, enum, unsigned, typedef
  2. arrays and classes are really pointers!!

C++ Arrays vs Java Arrays

  • In C++, when you declare an array, storage for the array is allocated. In Java, when you declare an array, you are really only declaring a pointer to an array; storage for the array itself is not allocated until you use "new":
                 C++                                int A[10];  // A is an array of length 10	     A[0] = 5;   // set the 1st element of array A                                                 JAVA  int [] A;          // A is a pointer to an array A = new int [10];  // now A points to an array of length 10 A[0] = 5;          // set the 1st element of the array pointed to by A 
  • In both C++ and Java you can initialize an array using values in curly braces. Here's example Java code:
      int [] A = {1, 222, 0};  // A points to an array of length 3                          // containing the values 1, 222, and 0 
  • In Java, a default initial value is assigned to each element of a newly allocated array if no initial value is specified. The default value depends on the type of the array element:
    TypeValue
    booleanfalse
    char'\u0000'
    byte, int, short, int, long, float, double0
    any pointernull

  • In Java, an out-of-bounds array index always causes a runtime error.

  • In Java, you can determine the current length of an array (at runtime) using ".length":
      int [] A = new int[10];     ...  A.length ...        // this expression evaluates to 10     A = new int[20];     ...  A.length ...        // now it evaluates to 20 

TEST YOURSELF #3

Write a Java function called NonZeros, using the header given below. NonZeros should create and return an array of integers containing all of the non-zero values in its parameter A, in the same order that they occur in A.

    public static int[] NonZeros( int [] A ) 

Write a complete Java program that includes a main function as well as the NonZeros function. The main function should test NonZeros by creating several arrays, and calling NonZeros with each array. It should print the array it passes to NonZeros as well as the returned array. So for example, when you run your program, your output might look like this (if your NonZeros function is implemented correctly):

    passing [0,1,2,3,2] got back [1,2,3,2]     passing [0,0] got back []     passing [22,0,-5,0,126] got back [22,-5,126]     passing [1,0] got back [1] 

solution



TEST YOURSELF #4

For each of the following code fragments, fill in the number of the picture that best illustrates the value of A after the code executes, or fill in "error" to indicate that executing the code causes a runtime error. (In the pictures, a diagonal line indicates a null pointer.)

CodeCorresponding Picture or Error
int [] A;
int [] A = new int [4];
int [][] A = new int[4][3];
int [][] A = new int[4][];
A[1] = new int[4];
A[3] = new int[2];
int [] A = new int[4];
int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};
System.arraycopy(B,2,A,0,4);
int [] A = new int[4];
int [] B = {2,3,4};
System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,4);
int [] A = new int[4];
int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};
System.arraycopy(B,8,A,0,4);
int [] A = {1,1,1,1};
int [] B = {2,2,2};
System.arraycopy(A,0,B,1,2);
System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,3);
int [] A = new int[4];
int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};
System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,10);
int [][] A = new int[4][3];
int [] B = {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10};
System.arraycopy(B,0,A[0],0,3);
System.arraycopy(B,1,A[1],0,3);
System.arraycopy(B,2,A[2],0,3);
System.arraycopy(B,3,A[3],0,3);

PICTURES

(1)(2)(3)

(4)(5)(6)

(7)(8)(9)

(10)(11)(12)
(13)(14)(15)

solution


C++ Classes vs Java Classes

  • In C++, when you declare a variable whose type is a class, storage is allocated for an object of that class, and the class's constructor function is called to initialize that instance of the class. In Java, you are really declaring a pointer to a class object; no storage is allocated for the class object, and no constructor function is called until you use "new". Assume that you have defined a List class as follows:
      class List {   public void AddToEnd(...)   { ...}   ... } 
                 C++  List L;          // L is a List; the List constructor function is called to                  // initialize L. List *p;         // p is a pointer to a List;                  // no list object exists yet, no constructor function has 		 // been called p = new List;    // now storage for a List has been allocated                  // and the constructor function has been called L.AddToEnd(...)  // call L's AddToEnd function p->AddToEnd(...) // call the AddToEnd function of the List pointed to by p                                                  JAVA  List L;         // L is a pointer to a List; no List object exists yet L = new List(); // now storage for a List has been allocated                 // and the constructor function has been called; 		// note that you must use parentheses even when you are not 		// passing any arguments to the constructor function L.AddToEnd(...) // no -> operator in Java -- just use . 

Aliasing Problems in Java

The fact that arrays and classes are really pointers in Java can lead to some problems:

Problem 1: Simple assignment causes aliasing:

Java code                          conceptual picture                                           (all empty boxes contain zeros)                                        +--+       +---+---+---+ int [] A = new int[3],             A: | -|-----> |   |   |   |                                       +--+       +---+---+---+         B = new int[2];                +--+       +---+---+                                    B: | -|-----> |   |   |                                       +--+       +---+---+                                        +--+       +---+---+---+        A[0] = 5;                   A: | -|-----> | 5 |   |   |                                       +--+       +---+---+---+                                        +--+       +---+---+---+        B = A;                      A: | -|-----> | 5 |   |   |                                       +--+       +---+---+---+ 				                 ^ 				      +--+       | 				   B: | -|-------+ 				      +--+                                        +--+       +---+---+---+ *** NOTE **         B[0] = 2;                  A: | -|-----> | 2 |   |   | the value of A[0]                                       +--+       +---+---+---+ changed, too! 				                 ^ 				      +--+       | 				   B: | -|-------+ 				      +--+  

Problem 2: In Java, all parameters are passed by value, but for arrays and classes the actual parameter is really a pointer, so changing

  • an array element, or
  • a class field
inside the function does change the actual parameter's element or field. For example:
void f( int [] A ) {     A[0] = 10;   // change an element of parameter A     A = null;    // change A itself }  void g() {     int [] B = new int [3];     B[0] = 5;     f(B);     *** B is not null here, because B itself was passed by value     *** however, B[0] is now 10, because function f changed the first element     *** of the array }  
In C++, similar problems can arise when a class that has pointer data members is passed by value. This problem is addressed by the use of copy constructors, which can be defined to make copies of the values pointed to, rather than just making copies of the pointers. In Java, the solution is to use the arraycopy operation, or to use a class's clone operation. Cloning will be discussed later.
TEST YOURSELF #5

For each of the following Java code fragments, say whether it causes a compile-time error, a run-time error, or no error. If there is an error, explain why.

   1. int A[5];     2. int [] A, B;       B = 0;     3. int [] A = {1,2,3};       int [] B;       B = A;     4. int [] A;       A[0] = 0;     5. int [] A = new int[20];       int [] B = new int[10];       A = B;       A[15] = 0; 

solution


Type Conversion

Java is much more limited than C++ in the type conversions that are allowed. Here we discuss conversions among primitive types. Conversions among class objects will be discussed later.

Booleans cannot be converted to other types. For the other primitive types (char, byte, short, int, long, float, and double), there are two kinds of conversion: implicit and explicit.

Implicit conversions: An implicit conversion means that a value of one type is changed to a value of another type without any special directive from the programmer. A char can be implicitly converted to an int, a long, a float, or a double. For example, the following will compile without error:

    char c = 'a'; int k = c; long x = c; float y = c; double d = c; 
For the other (numeric) primitive types, the basic rule is that implicit conversions can be done from one type to another if the range of values of the first type is a subset of the range of values of the second type. For example, a byte can be converted to a short, int, long or float; a short can be converted to an int, long, float, or double, etc.

Explicit conversions: Explicit conversions are done via casting: the name of the type to which you want a value converted is given, in parentheses, in front of the value. For example, the following code uses casts to convert a value of type double to a value of type int, and to convert a value of type double to a value of type short:

    double d = 5.6; int k = (int)d; short s = (short)(d * 2.0); 
Casting can be used to convert among any of the primitive types except boolean. Note, however, that casting can lose information; for example, floating-point values are truncated when they are cast to integers (e.g., the value of k in the code fragment given above is 5), and casting among integer types can produce wildly different values (because upper bits, possibly including the sign bit, are lost). So use explicit casting carefully!
TEST YOURSELF #6

Fill in the table below as follows:

  • If the declaration will compile as is, put a check in the second column, and write the value of the declared variable in the last column.
  • If the declaration will not compile as is, but can be made to compile by adding an explicit cast, rewrite the declaration with the correct explicit cast in the third column, and write the value of the declared variable in the last column.
  • If the declaration will not compile, and cannot be fixed by adding an explicit cast, put a check in the fourth column.
The first row has been filled in as an example.

DeclarationCorrectRewrite with castNever correctVariable's value
double d = 5;X5.0
int k = 5.6;
long x = 5.4;
short n = 99999;
int b = true;
char c = 97;
short s = -10.0;

solution


Solutions to Self-Study Questions

Test Yourself #1

    System.out.println(x + y);                  ==>     30 System.out.println(x + y+ "!");             ==>     30! System.out.println("printing: " + x + y);   ==>     printing: 2010 System.out.println("printing: " + x * y);   ==>     printing: 200 

Test Yourself #2

    class Test {   public static void main( String[] args ) {     int sum = 0;     for (int k=1; k<=10; k++) sum += k;     System.out.println("The sum is: " + sum);   } } 

Test Yourself #3

    class Test {   public static int[] NonZeros( int[] A ) {     // count # nonzero values       int nonz = 0;       for (int k=0; k

Test Yourself #4

            CODE                    CORRESPONDING PICTURE         ----                    ---------------------     int [] A;                           9      int [] A = new int[4];              6      int [][] A = new int[4][3];         3      int [][] A = new int[4][];     A[1] = new int[4];     A[3] = new int[2];                  1      int [] A = new int[4];     int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};     System.arraycopy(B,2,A,0,4);        14      int [] A = new int[4];     int [] B = {2,3,4};     System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,4);        error      int [] A = new int[4];     int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};     System.arraycopy(B,8,A,0,4);        error      int [] A = {1,1,1,1};     int [] B = {2,2,2};     System.arraycopy(A,0,B,1,2);     System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,3);        12      int [] A = new int[4];     int [] B = {0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9};     System.arraycopy(B,0,A,0,10);       error      int [][] A = new int[4][3];     int [] B = {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10};     System.arraycopy(B,0,A[0],0,3);     System.arraycopy(B,1,A[1],0,3);     System.arraycopy(B,2,A[2],0,3);     System.arraycopy(B,3,A[3],0,3);     10 

Test Yourself #5

        int A[5];         Compile-time error: Can't specify array dimension in a declaration.         This is C/C++ syntax.      int [] A, B;     B = 0;         Compile-time error: Incompatible type for =. Can't convert int to         int[].  B is an array reference, not an int, and 0 is not equiv to         null as in C/C++.      int [] A = {1,2,3};     int [] B;     B = A;         No errors.      int [] A;     A[0] = 0;         Compile-time error: Variable A may not have been initialized.         The array was never allocated.      int [] A = new int[20];     int [] B = new int[10];     A = B;     A[15] = 0;         Runtime error: ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException: 15         A now references the same array as B, which only has length 10 

Test Yourself #6

    Declaration     Correct   Rewrite with cast   Never correct   Variable's value  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ double d = 5;      X                                              5.0 int k = 5.6;              int k = (int) 5.6                       5 long x = 5.4;            long x = (long) 5.4                      5 short n = 99999;        short n = (short) 99999                   -31073 int b = true;                                      X char c = 97;       X                                              'a'  short s = -10.0;        short s = (short) -10.0                   -10

No comments:

Post a Comment